Rookie quarterback Tommy DeVito was benched in the New York Giants’ recent 33-25 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles, with Tyrod Taylor taking over in the second half at Lincoln Financial Field on Monday. The decision stemmed from the team’s lackluster first-half performance, where they managed only 101 total yards and three points, abruptly halting DeVito’s rise as a fan-favorite underdog.

Coach Brian Daboll, in his postgame conference, explained that the switch was aimed at sparking the team’s performance. The Giants, now 5-10 for the season, bounced back with Taylor leading the offense in the second half, scoring on their opening possession and adding a 69-yard touchdown pass to Darius Slayton.

The team faces a dilemma moving forward: Start DeVito to prioritize the development of the young quarterback and gain more game experience. Start the veteran Taylor to emphasize winning games despite the season already being lost.

Daboll remained non-committal about the future, stating, “I’m just worried about (Monday) here. We’ll talk about that here this week.”

DeVito, known for his unexpected success in the past few weeks, was informed of the switch at halftime and expressed understanding of the business aspect of the decision. Despite the disappointment, he maintained a professional outlook, stating, “It’s your job. I respect it. There’s no hard feelings one way or another.”

The rookie’s popularity soared three weeks ago after a comeback win against the Green Bay Packers, but recent offensive struggles raised questions about his continued role. Taylor’s performance on Monday further complicates the decision.

DeVito, reflecting on the situation, acknowledged the competitive nature of the sport and expressed uncertainty about his role in the upcoming games. Taylor, while disappointed with not being named the starter earlier, remained focused on being ready when called upon.

The Christmas Day game may mark the end of DeVito’s unexpected journey, with the Giants facing challenges in reaching the end zone. Despite the uncertainty, DeVito maintains a work-focused mindset, appreciating every opportunity and remaining resilient in the face of potential changes.

Just a week prior, Coach Daboll had affirmed DeVito as the starter, emphasizing that he had earned the opportunity. However, recent developments cast doubt on whether that endorsement still holds true.